Set out the assorted capital requirements imposed by regulators.
The idea
Regulators set several capital and margin requirements around collateral. Under Basel III, counterparty credit exposure uses SA-CCR, the standardized approach. Here RC is replacement cost, PFE is potential future exposure, and alpha is 1.4. EAD = α × (RC + PFE). For margined netting sets, V is the contract value, C the collateral held, TH the threshold and NICA the net independent collateral amount. Replacement cost recognises that unsecured exposure can persist. RC = max(V − C, TH + MTA − NICA, 0). Here RW is the risk weight, and 8% is the minimum capital ratio on risk-weighted assets. Capital = EAD × RW × 8%. There is a separate CVA capital charge. In the comprehensive approach, E is the exposure, C the collateral, and the H terms are haircuts. Here NE is the net exposure after haircuts. NE = max(0, E × (1 + He) − C × (1 − Hc − Hfx)). The BCBS-IOSCO rules require variation and initial margin on non-cleared derivatives between covered entities. Initial margin is calibrated to a 99% one-tailed, 10-day stress and is segregated. Know the formulas and the 99% and 10-day parameters.
Formulas
SA-CCR exposure at default
EAD = α × (RC + PFE)
- α
- the alpha multiplier, 1.4
- RC
- replacement cost, the current exposure
- PFE
- potential future exposure
Netting sets under Basel III's standardised approach. Alpha multiplies the whole sum; applying it to RC alone, or leaving it out, is the usual slip.
SA-CCR replacement cost of a margined netting set
RC = max(V − C, TH + MTA − NICA, 0)
- V
- the current value of the contracts
- C
- the collateral held
- TH
- the threshold
- MTA
- the minimum transfer amount
- NICA
- the net independent collateral amount
Margined netting sets only. The middle term is a floor for exposure that can persist unsecured; using V − C alone misses it.
Counterparty credit capital
Capital = EAD × RW × 8%
- EAD
- exposure at default
- RW
- the counterparty risk weight
EAD × RW is risk-weighted assets; capital is 8% of that. A separate CVA capital charge is added on top.
Net exposure under the comprehensive approach
NE = max(0, E × (1 + He) − C × (1 − Hc − Hfx))
- E
- the exposure
- He
- the haircut on the exposure
- C
- the market value of the collateral
- Hc
- the supervisory haircut on the collateral
- Hfx
- the extra haircut for a currency mismatch
Collateralised exposures. Both collateral haircuts reduce the collateral; leaving out Hfx when the currencies differ overstates the protection.
A practice question
In the Basel SA-CCR framework, exposure at default for a netting set is:
- 1.4 x potential future exposure onlyWhy not: Omits replacement cost, the current exposure.
- Replacement cost + potential future exposure, with no scalingWhy not: Omits the alpha factor of 1.4.
- Replacement cost x 1.4 less collateral heldWhy not: Treats alpha as applying to replacement cost only and subtracts collateral again.
- 1.4 x (replacement cost + potential future exposure) - correct
SA-CCR sets EAD = alpha x (RC + PFE), with alpha equal to 1.4.
A harder one
A margined netting set has mark-to-market V = USD 12 million, collateral held C = USD 8 million, threshold 5 million, MTA 1 million and a net independent collateral amount of zero. Replacement cost under SA-CCR is closest to:
- USD 6 million - correct
- USD 5 millionWhy not: Uses the threshold alone and omits the MTA.
- USD 4 millionWhy not: Uses V - C only and misses the floor of threshold plus MTA.
- USD 12 millionWhy not: Ignores collateral, which is the unmargined formula.
RC = max(V - C, TH + MTA - NICA, 0) = max(4, 6, 0) = USD 6 million.
The hardest tier
A bank has a USD 100 million loan (no exposure haircut) secured by bonds with market value USD 60 million. The supervisory haircut on the bonds is 4%, and an additional 8% FX haircut applies for a currency mismatch. Under the comprehensive approach, net exposure is closest to:
- USD 40.0 millionWhy not: Ignores both haircuts and subtracts full market value of the bonds.
- USD 42.4 millionWhy not: Omits the FX haircut, using 60 x (1 - 0.04) as collateral value.
- USD 47.2 million - correct
- USD 52.8 millionWhy not: Reports the haircut-adjusted collateral value instead of the net exposure.
E* = max(0, 100 - 60 x (1 - 0.04 - 0.08)) = 100 - 52.8 = USD 47.2 million.
In the app: 6 practice questions on this outcome, spaced review that brings it back before you forget it.
Start free →More in Margin (Collateral) and Settlement
- Outline why collateral is managed.
- Set out the terms found in a collateral agreement and the main features of a credit support annex (CSA) in an ISDA Master Agreement: credit support amount, credit quality, haircuts, rounding, minimum transfer amount, initial margin and threshold.
- Compute the margin, meaning the credit support amount, under a number of different scenarios.
- Outline what a valuation agent does.
- Outline how collateral operates in practice and the kinds of collateral commonly used.
- Account for how disputes over collateral are reconciled.
- Spell out what a collateralization agreement typically contains.
- Distinguish CSAs that run one way from those that run both ways, and describe how collateral parameters can depend on credit quality.
- Account for collateral-related aspects such as funding, rehypothecation and segregation.
- Show how collateralization can bring about market risk, operational risk and liquidity risk, funding liquidity risk included.