Name the various origins of country risk and explain each.
The idea
Country risk is the extra uncertainty a cash flow carries because of where it is earned, and it has four main origins. First, the stage of the economic life cycle matters, because young, fast-growing economies have short histories, thin information and volatile earnings. Second, political risk can be continuous (shifts in tax, regulation or policy) or discontinuous (expropriation, nationalisation, violence, regime change). Third, legal risk is how well courts enforce contracts and protect property rights, and it is separate from political stability. Fourth, economic structure matters, because dependence on one commodity, sector or trading partner makes the whole economy hostage to a single shock. The origins overlap but are distinct, and the usual error is to treat one of them as the whole story. Continuous risk goes into expected cash flows or discount rates. Discontinuous risk is usually handled by probability-weighted scenarios or insurance.
A practice question
A risk manager is asked to list the fundamental sources from which country risk arises. Which list is correct?
- The country's stage in its economic life cycle, its political structure, its legal system and its economic structure. - correct
- Interest rate level, exchange rate regime, inflation rate and GDP growth. These are outcomes that reflect country risk; they do not themselves explain why the risk exists.Why not: Lists macroeconomic indicators that show country risk instead of the underlying origins that produce it.
- Sovereign rating, CDS spread, political risk score and bond yield spread.Why not: Lists measures of country risk, not its origins, so it confuses measurement with source.
- Currency risk, interest rate risk, liquidity risk and operational risk.Why not: Lists generic financial risk types that exist in any country, rather than country-specific origins.
Country risk originates in life cycle (how mature the economy is), political risk, legal risk and economic structure. Ratings and spreads are ways to measure the result, and macro variables are symptoms.
A harder one
Country X earns about 70 percent of its export revenue and most of its government revenue from a single commodity. When the price halves, the budget deficit widens and the currency weakens sharply. Which origin of country risk is most clearly illustrated?
- Continuous political risk, because falling commodity prices change government policy.Why not: Policy changes may follow, but the root cause identified in the stem is concentration, not a political process.
- Legal risk, because export contracts become harder to enforce when prices fall.Why not: The stem says nothing about courts or contract enforcement.
- Life cycle risk, because every commodity exporter is at an early stage of development.Why not: Commodity dependence is not an indicator of life cycle; mature economies can also be concentrated.
- Economic structure, because concentration makes the whole economy depend on one price. - correct
Dependence on one commodity ties exports, fiscal revenue and the exchange rate to a single price, which is the economic structure origin. Diversification of the economy is the remedy.
The hardest tier
A multinational evaluates a country with a stable government, orderly elections and a diversified economy. However, courts are slow, rulings are inconsistent, and contract and property rights are routinely renegotiated. Which conclusion is most accurate?
- Political risk must also be high, because weak courts are a form of discontinuous political risk.Why not: Discontinuous political risk is expropriation or regime change; weak courts are a separate legal origin.
- Country risk is low overall, because a stable government implies that every other origin is also benign.Why not: Treats one origin as a proxy for all; the origins are distinct and the legal weakness remains.
- Legal risk is high even though political risk is low, because stable government does not guarantee enforceable property rights. - correct
- Country risk is high only if the economy is undiversified, so the investor can ignore the courts.Why not: Diversification addresses economic structure; it does not offset weak enforcement of contracts and property.
The four origins are separate. Political stability and diversification do not remove the risk that contracts and property rights cannot be enforced, so legal risk must be assessed on its own.
In the app: 6 practice questions on this outcome, spaced review that brings it back before you forget it.
Start free →More in Country Risk: Determinants, Measures, and Implications
- Weigh up the ways country risk is measured and review the weaknesses of those ways.
- Compare what happens when a sovereign defaults on foreign currency obligations versus local currency ones.
- Account for what follows when a country defaults.
- Review how sovereign default risk is measured and outline what goes into a sovereign rating.
- Outline where the sovereign rating systems used by rating agencies fall short.
- Weigh CDS spreads, market-based credit default spreads and credit ratings against one another as default predictors, judging which is more reliable.