Charta is on Google Play: practise on the go.Get the app
CFA® Level I question of the day
18 November 2026 · Equities
A share trades at $46.00. An analyst's model gives an intrinsic value of $50.00, and the model's estimates have historically differed from realised value by $5.00 on average. What conclusion does the evidence support?
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: A. The $4.00 gap is within the model's $5.00 typical error, so it is weak evidence
Intrinsic value is a model estimate, and every estimate is wrong by some amount. Gap = Intrinsic value - Price = 50.00 - 46.00 = $4.00. The model has typically been wrong by $5.00, so a $4.00 gap is smaller than its normal error and cannot be told apart from noise. It is not reliable evidence of mispricing, and acting on it treats noise as information. Intrinsic value cannot be observed, so a gap is at least as likely to be a flaw in the model as a mispricing in the market. The $5.00 error is uncertainty in both directions, not an amount to subtract.
Why the other options are wrong:
B. The share is undervalued by $4.00, which is enough to justify buying it - A gap smaller than the model's typical error is not evidence of mispricing. Acting on it treats estimation noise as information.
C. The share is overvalued by $1.00 once the $5.00 error is deducted - The average error is two-sided uncertainty around the estimate, not a haircut to be subtracted from it. Deducting it in one direction invents a precision the model does not have.