Charta is on Google Play: practise on the go. Get the app

Describe presentation choices, including non-GAAP measures, that could be used to influence an analyst's opinion

CFA® Level I · Financial Statement Analysis · Financial Reporting Quality · FSA.10.d

The idea

Companies choose how to present their results. Many publish adjusted measures beside the reported ones, such as adjusted operating profit, adjusted earnings per share, or EBITDA with extra items removed. Under US rules these are non-GAAP measures; under IFRS they are management performance measures. No standard defines them, so each company decides what to leave out. Items often removed are restructuring costs, share-based pay and amortisation of acquired intangibles; some are real, recurring costs, so removing them can flatter profit. Regulators require a reconciliation to the nearest reported figure, and in the US the reported figure must not be given less prominence. The analyst starts from the reported figure, reads the reconciliation and asks of each item whether it will recur.

A practice question

From the question bank, with the reason each wrong option is wrong.

What is a non-GAAP measure?

  1. A figure a company presents that the accounting standards do not define, such as adjusted operating profit - correct
  2. A figure the regulator has audited and approved before it is publishedWhy not: Backwards. Companies choose these figures themselves, and the regulator does not approve them in advance. It only requires a reconciliation to a reported figure.
  3. A figure prepared under IFRS but not under US GAAPWhy not: The label is about the measure not being defined by the standards. It is not a choice between IFRS and US GAAP.

A non-GAAP measure is one the company chooses to present beside its reported figures, such as adjusted operating profit or adjusted earnings per share. No accounting standard defines it, so the company decides what to leave out. Under IFRS the same idea is called a management performance measure.

A harder one

A company has called a restructuring charge 'one-off' in each of the last four years. What should an analyst conclude?

  1. The label shows the charge will not repeat, so it can safely be ignoredWhy not: Four years in a row is evidence that the charge recurs. A label is the company's choice, not proof.
  2. The charge recurs, so it should be treated as a normal operating cost - correct
  3. The charge can be ignored because it is non-cashWhy not: Restructuring usually involves cash payments such as severance and closure costs, and the label says nothing about cash.

An item that appears every year is part of running the business, whatever it is called. Serial one-off charges are a red flag because they move recurring costs out of the adjusted profit. The analyst leaves the cost in operating profit.

The hardest tier

Reported operating profit is $150m. The company adds back a first-ever restructuring charge of $10m, share-based pay of $25m and amortisation of acquired intangibles of $20m. An analyst accepts the genuine one-off restructuring and the non-cash amortisation, but keeps share-based pay as a real cost. What operating profit does the analyst use, and how far above reported is it?

  1. $205m, which is 37% above reportedWhy not: This is the company's figure, 150 + 10 + 25 + 20 = 205. It accepts every add-back, including the real cost of share-based pay.
  2. $160m, which is 7% above reportedWhy not: This adds back only the restructuring. The amortisation is also a non-cash charge for a past deal, so the analyst adds it back too.
  3. $180m, which is 20% above reported - correct

The analyst adds back restructuring of 10 and amortisation of 20 but keeps share-based pay in. Operating profit is 150 + 10 + 20 = 180. Against reported profit of 150 that is 30 higher, and 30 ÷ 150 = 20%. The company's figure is 205, which is 55 higher, and 55 ÷ 150 is about 37%.

In the app: 9 practice questions on this outcome, spaced review that brings it back before you forget it.

Take the free diagnostic →

More in Financial Reporting Quality