Critical Reasoning question types, and how to read each one
Critical Reasoning questions are part of the Verbal Reasoning section of the GMAT™ exam, alongside Reading Comprehension. Each gives you a short passage, usually an argument of a few sentences, and a question about it, with five answers. The passages vary endlessly, but the questions do not: there are a handful of types, and each one asks for a particular job. Recognising the type before you read the answers is most of the skill.
First, find the argument
Most passages are arguments: a conclusion the author wants you to accept, and premises offered as reasons for it. Before anything else, find the conclusion. Words like "therefore", "so" and "clearly" often point to it, but not always; ask "what is the author trying to persuade me of?". Then find the gap: what the author takes for granted in moving from the premises to the conclusion. Almost every question type is about that gap.
A short example to use throughout:
Since the town opened its new cycle lanes, the number of people cycling to work has doubled. So the cycle lanes have encouraged people to cycle.
The conclusion is that the lanes caused the rise. The gap: nothing else explains it.
The types
Assumption. "The argument depends on which of the following?" The right answer is something the argument needs to be true. A useful test: negate the answer. If the argument falls apart, it was an assumption. Here: "the rise in cycling was not mainly caused by a sharp increase in fuel prices over the same period".
Strengthen. "Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?" The right answer makes the conclusion more likely, usually by closing the gap. Here: "in a neighbouring town with no new cycle lanes, cycling to work was unchanged".
Weaken. The mirror image: the right answer makes the conclusion less likely, usually by opening the gap wider. Here: "the town's largest employer began paying staff to cycle to work in the same month".
Evaluate. "Which would it be most useful to know in judging the argument?" The right answer is a question whose answer could go either way and would strengthen or weaken the argument depending on which. Here: "did cycling rise in places without new lanes?".
Inference. "Which of the following can most properly be concluded?" There is no argument to attack here: you are given facts and must find what follows from them. The right answer is often modest and dull. Be wary of anything that goes even a little beyond what is stated.
Explain a discrepancy. Two facts seem to clash, and you must find what reconciles them. "Cycling doubled, yet the number of bicycles sold in the town fell." A right answer: "most new cyclists used the town's bicycle hire scheme". It has to explain both facts, not just one.
Role of a statement. Two parts of the passage are picked out, often in bold, and you must say what each does: a conclusion, a premise, evidence against the conclusion, a position the author rejects. Describe each part in your own words before you read the answers.
Flaw. "The reasoning is flawed because it..." Name the gap in general terms. Our example confuses a sequence with a cause: the rise came after the lanes, so the lanes are assumed to have caused it.
Plan. A proposal is put forward to achieve a goal, and you are asked what would make it more or less likely to work, or what it assumes. Treat it like an argument whose conclusion is "this plan will work".
The wrong answers
The wrong answers repeat a few patterns, and learning them is as useful as learning the types.
- Out of scope. True, perhaps interesting, but about something the argument does not discuss.
- Right idea, wrong direction. A strengthener offered on a weaken question, or the other way round. Read the question stem twice.
- Too strong. "All", "never", "always" in an inference answer is usually a sign it goes beyond the facts.
- Restates a premise. On a strengthen question, repeating what the passage already says adds nothing.
- Explains half the discrepancy. It accounts for one fact and leaves the other as puzzling as before.
A method for each question
- Read the question stem first, so you know the job.
- Read the passage and find the conclusion and the gap.
- Say in your own words what a right answer would do, before you look at the five.
- Eliminate, using the wrong answer patterns above, rather than hunting for the one that sounds best.
- Between the last two, choose the one that does the job most directly.
Verbal Reasoning gives you 45 minutes for 23 questions, a little under two minutes each, so the method has to become quick through practice.
Common questions
How many Critical Reasoning questions are there?
They share the 23 questions of Verbal Reasoning with Reading Comprehension, so prepare for both.
Do I need to know formal logic?
No. The questions test careful reading and everyday reasoning. Knowing that a conclusion can rest on an unstated assumption is far more useful than any notation.
Should I read the question or the passage first?
The question. Knowing whether you are looking for an assumption or a weakener changes what you notice in the passage.
Sources
- GMAC, the GMAT exam on mba.com: the Verbal Reasoning section and its two question types, Reading Comprehension and Critical Reasoning.
The question types and examples in this guide are Charta's own way of teaching the section, written for this course.