A revision flow chart for Critical Reasoning: the trap check
Critical Reasoning rewards a fixed routine more than cleverness. The flow below is the one to run on every question, and the table after it lists the trap each question type sets. Revise from this page the night before a practice test, and tick off the traps you fell for.
The flow
Read it from the top. Each box has one question; the arrow says where to go next.
1. Read the question stem. What is the job: assumption, strengthen, weaken, evaluate, inference, discrepancy, role of a statement, flaw or plan? Go to step 2. 2. Find the conclusion. Look for so, therefore and thus. With no signal word, use the WHY test: ask "why?" of each statement. A statement that has reasons given for it can be the conclusion; the reasons are the evidence. Go to step 3. 3. Name the gap. What new idea appears in the conclusion that the evidence never mentions? Go to step 4. 4. Predict the job of a right answer in your own words, before you read the choices. Go to step 5. 5. Read each choice and ask: does it do the job? - If it is about something the argument never discusses, it is out of scope: cross it out. - If it does the opposite job (a strengthener on a weaken question), cross it out. - If it only repeats the evidence, cross it out. - If it uses an extreme word (all, every, never, only, always, should) go to step 6. - Otherwise go to step 7. 6. Check the extreme word. An extreme word is a signal, not a verdict. Ask whether the argument needs that much. If the argument survives with less, the choice is too strong: cross it out. If the question is an inference question and the facts do not force it, cross it out. 7. Test the survivors. For an assumption question, negate the choice: if the argument collapses, it was needed. For strengthen or weaken, ask whether it changes how likely the conclusion is. For inference, ask whether it must be true on the facts alone. Choose the one that does the job most directly.
The trap each question type sets
| Question type | The trap | What gives it away |
|---|---|---|
| Assumption | A choice that would merely help the argument, or that is too strong | "All", "every", "never"; negate it and the argument survives |
| Strengthen | A choice that restates the evidence, or supports a different conclusion | Nothing new is added to the link |
| Weaken | A choice that attacks a side issue, or that actually strengthens | Read the stem twice: weaken, not strengthen |
| Evaluate | A question whose answer is already in the facts, or that questions the facts | The answer cannot change the conclusion either way |
| Inference | A choice that goes one step beyond the facts | "Most" for "some", "caused" for "followed" |
| Discrepancy | A choice that explains only one of the two facts, or deepens the puzzle | It leaves one fact as puzzling as before |
| Role of a statement | A choice that swaps the roles, or calls an intermediate conclusion the main one | Find the main conclusion first; the other statement either supports it or opposes it |
| Flaw | A real flaw that this argument does not commit | The flaw is true of arguments in general but not of this one |
| Plan | A choice about a different goal, or a side effect | Ask whether it makes the plan more or less likely to reach its stated goal |
For evaluate questions: two extra traps
- Never choose a question whose answer is already in the facts. If the passage says scores rose, asking whether scores rose tells you nothing.
- Never choose a question that doubts the facts. Whether the figures were recorded correctly questions the facts; the job is to question the conclusion.
For role-of-a-statement questions: three steps
1. Read the argument and find the main conclusion. 2. Ask whether both marked statements support or oppose a common topic, the one the conclusion is about. 3. Decide for each whether it is the conclusion or not, using these families of words: - Evidence: facts, information, the premise. - Reason: a consideration or an explanation. - Opinion: a claim, a judgement or a prediction. - A statement may also be a generalisation.
A last check before you move on
Ask: "If I had to defend my answer in one sentence, what would I say?" If the sentence has to include "it could be that" or "if we assume", you are probably looking at a trap.
Sources
- GMAC, the GMAT exam on mba.com: the Verbal Reasoning section and its Critical Reasoning question type.
The routine and the traps are Charta's own way of teaching the section, written for this course.