CFA® Level I question of the day
12 November 2026 · Portfolio Construction
Gareth Doyle, 68, retired last year. His $900,000 portfolio must fund withdrawals of $54,000 a year, and he has no pension or other assets. On the adviser's questionnaire he scored as a very aggressive investor and says he is comfortable with falls of 35% in value. The adviser judges that his ability to take risk is low. Which should the adviser use as the basis for his risk tolerance in the investment policy statement?
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: C. Ability, since it is the lower of the two
Risk tolerance has two parts. Ability is objective and comes from wealth, income and how much the money is needed. Willingness is how comfortable the client feels about risk. Gareth's withdrawals are 54,000 / 900,000 = 6.0% of the portfolio, and he has no other income. A 35% fall would force heavy selling to fund them, so his ability is low even though his willingness is high. Rule: use the lower of the two. The adviser should also discuss the gap with him. Averaging would reflect neither.
- A. Willingness, since it is the client's own choice - Willingness is psychological and does not create capacity. A 35% fall would force Gareth to sell heavily to fund withdrawals, so a stated preference cannot override what the finances can bear.
- B. The average of the two, since both matter - An average gives a figure that reflects neither component and still commits him to more risk than his finances can support. The prudent rule is to adopt the lower of ability and willingness.
Get a new question every day with spaced review, so the ones you miss come back before you forget them.
Take the free diagnostic →More on Portfolio Construction
Notes, formulas and a worked question for every learning outcome are on the Portfolio Construction page, with the whole CFA Level I syllabus alongside.