Charta is on Google Play: practise on the go.Get the app
CFA® Level I question of the day
13 November 2026 · Financial Statement Analysis
Two insurers report under US GAAP and hold identical bond portfolios, yet they report very different earnings volatility. What is the most likely cause?
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: B. Different classification of the same bonds
The portfolios are identical, so the difference must come from how they are labelled. Rule: where a bond's price change is reported depends on its label. Trading bonds: price changes go straight into profit. Available for sale bonds: price changes go to other comprehensive income, a section of equity outside profit. Held to maturity bonds: price changes are not recorded. Example: if bond prices fall by $5 million, the trading insurer reports a $5 million loss in profit, while the available for sale insurer shows it in equity. Tax rates and auditors do not change how swingy profit is.
Why the other options are wrong:
A. Different tax rates on investment income - Tax rates scale after-tax earnings, but they would not make one insurer's earnings swing with bond prices while the other's stay steady.
C. Different audit firms reviewing the portfolios - Auditors assess whether the treatment is acceptable. They do not produce a different earnings path from the same holdings under the same standards.