How an audit works, from planning to opinion
An audit looks like a pile of checking, but it follows a logic: understand the client, set a threshold for what matters, gather evidence where the risk is highest, add up what you find and decide what it means for the opinion. This guide walks through that sequence for an invented company, with figures worked out in full. Practice varies by firm and jurisdiction; this is a simplified teaching version.
What is the auditor trying to do?
The auditor gives an opinion on whether the financial statements give a true and fair view (or are fairly presented, depending on the framework) and are free from material misstatement. The assurance is reasonable, which is high but not absolute. Auditors test samples, rely on judgement and cannot see everything, which is one reason an audit is not a guarantee that no error or fraud exists.
What are the main stages?
- Acceptance and understanding. Decide whether to take the client and learn its business, industry and controls.
- Risk assessment. Identify where the statements could be wrong, for example revenue recognised too early.
- Materiality. Set the size of error that would influence a user's decisions.
- Procedures. Design tests that respond to the risks and gather evidence.
- Evaluation. Add up the misstatements found and compare them with materiality.
- Reporting. Conclude and issue the opinion, after discussing the findings with management and those charged with governance.
What is materiality and how is it set?
A misstatement is material if it could reasonably influence the decisions users take on the basis of the statements. Auditors set a number as a starting point using a common rule of thumb: a percentage of a benchmark, often profit before tax for a profit-making company, or revenue or assets for others. The percentage and benchmark are judgements that vary by firm, client and circumstances. Auditors also set a lower performance materiality, so that the total of many small undetected errors does not exceed overall materiality, and a clearly trivial threshold below which items are not accumulated.
What does a worked example look like?
Tarnworth Cycles plc is an invented retailer with revenue of 142.0m and profit before tax of 9.6m for the year. The audit team chooses profit before tax as the benchmark.
- Overall materiality at 5 percent of 9.6m: 0.48m.
- Performance materiality at 75 percent of overall: 0.36m.
- Clearly trivial at 5 percent of overall materiality: 0.024m.
Overall materiality of 0.48m is about 0.34 percent of revenue, which is a useful sense check. These percentages are illustrative rule-of-thumb choices, not requirements.
Which risks and procedures matter here?
The team identifies three areas. Revenue cut-off is a risk because sales just before the year-end might be recorded when goods have not yet been delivered. Inventory is a risk because the physical count may differ from the records. Receivables are a risk because customers may not pay, and the balance is large. The procedures respond to each: tracing shipments around the year-end to dispatch documents, attending the count and re-counting selected items, and confirming a sample of receivables with customers.
What did the testing find?
- Cut-off. Goods with a selling price of 0.31m and a cost of 0.19m were recorded as December sales, but were dispatched in January. Revenue is overstated by 0.31m, and since cost of sales was also recorded early, the effect on profit is 0.31m minus 0.19m, which is 0.12m.
- Inventory. The count shows that inventory on the books is overstated by 0.22m because of items damaged and not written down. Profit is overstated by 0.22m.
- Receivables. The team tested a sample worth 3.0m out of a population of 18.0m and found errors of 0.025m. Projecting the error to the population: 0.025 divided by 3.0, multiplied by 18.0, is 0.15m.
The projection is an estimate. It assumes the sample is representative of the whole population, which is why the way a sample is chosen matters.
How are the misstatements added up?
Total effect on profit: 0.12m plus 0.22m plus 0.15m is 0.49m. Compare this with overall materiality of 0.48m: it exceeds the threshold by 0.01m. Each item alone is below materiality, and the receivables projection is only an estimate, but together they are above it. The total also exceeds performance materiality of 0.36m, which is a warning in itself that further uncovered errors could be material.
What does the auditor do next?
The auditor reports the misstatements to management and asks for adjustment. If management corrects them, the total uncorrected misstatement falls and the opinion can be unmodified. Suppose management corrects the cut-off and inventory errors (0.12m plus 0.22m, which is 0.34m). The uncorrected total is then the 0.15m projection, below 0.48m, and the auditor would consider whether to extend testing on receivables, since the projected error was an estimate. If management refused to correct anything and the 0.49m remained, the auditor would consider whether the effect on the statements is material and, if so, whether a qualified opinion is needed. These conclusions require judgement, including qualitative factors such as whether an error turns a profit into a loss, affects a covenant or involves possible fraud.
What should I take from this?
Four points. Materiality is a judgement based on rules of thumb, not a formula that settles everything. Procedures follow risk, not the other way round. Misstatements are accumulated and compared with thresholds, and projected errors from samples are estimates. And the opinion is a reasoned conclusion, not a count of errors. In an interview, being able to talk through this chain in plain words matters more than quoting numbers.
What to do this week
- Recompute the example by hand and confirm each figure.
- Change the benchmark to revenue at 0.5 percent and note how materiality changes.
- Explain in two sentences why performance materiality is lower than overall materiality.
- Describe a procedure for each of cut-off, inventory and receivables.
- Say aloud what you would tell a manager if the total misstatement were just over materiality.
About this guide: it is original to Charta Learning and has not yet been reviewed by an experienced practitioner. Names in examples are invented. The percentages and thresholds shown are illustrative rules of thumb, and real practice depends on the firm, the framework and the jurisdiction.