How to do a paper LBO in four minutes
A paper LBO is a leveraged buyout worked by hand, with no spreadsheet, in a few minutes. It tests whether you understand how a buyout earns its return and can organise numbers under time pressure. The aim is a sensible estimate, not an exact answer.
Set it out on one page
Draw four boxes before you calculate anything and fill them in order.
- Entry. Entry enterprise value (EV) is earnings times the entry multiple. Debt is a multiple of the same earnings. Equity is what is left, plus fees if given.
- Operating forecast. Earnings for each year of the holding period, and the cash flow available to repay debt.
- Debt. Opening debt, interest, repayment and closing debt, year by year.
- Exit. Exit EV is exit-year earnings times the exit multiple. Subtract closing debt to get exit equity. Divide by entry equity to get the money multiple, then convert to an annual return.
Write the conventions at the top first: "no fees, a five-year hold, interest on opening debt, all spare cash repays debt". It takes ten seconds and shows you know the choices exist.
Round for speed, not for neatness
- Use round numbers. If the question gives awkward figures, round them to two significant figures and say so.
- Work to the nearest 5 or 10 in the debt schedule.
- Estimate interest on the average of opening and closing debt, or simply on opening debt, and say which. Avoid circular calculations.
- Round the answer too. "About 2.7 times, a little over 20% a year" is a good paper answer. "21.8%" suggests false precision.
The returns shortcut
Once you have a money multiple over a number of years, you do not need to solve for the annual return exactly. Remember a few points for a five-year hold:
| Money multiple | Approximate annual return |
|---|---|
| 1.5 times | 8% |
| 2.0 times | 15% |
| 2.5 times | 20% |
| 3.0 times | 25% |
Between these, interpolate. For other holds, doubling your money takes a little over 7% a year for ten years, and about 26% for three.
This assumes one cash flow in and one out, the usual paper convention.
Where the return comes from
After the calculation, say where the return came from. There are three sources:
- Earnings growth, which raises exit EV at a constant multiple.
- Change in the multiple, which adds or subtracts from exit EV. Many candidates assume the multiple stays the same at exit as at entry. That is a conservative, common convention, and you should say that it is one.
- Debt repayment, which transfers value from debt to equity as the debt falls.
Splitting the gain into these three is often worth more than the headline return.
Worked example
The company is invented and the figures are for practice only. The conventions are: figures in millions; no fees; a five-year hold; interest at 8% of opening debt; no tax shield on interest (tax is already inside the cash conversion below); the cash flow available before interest is 45% of that year's earnings and all of what remains after interest repays debt; exit multiple equal to entry multiple.
Entry. Earnings are 100. The entry multiple is 8.0 times, so EV is 800. Debt is 5.0 times earnings, which is 500. Equity is 800 minus 500, which is 300.
Forecast. Earnings grow by 10 a year: 110, 120, 130, 140 and 150 in years 1 to 5.
Debt schedule (exact figures to one decimal place):
| Year | Earnings | Cash flow before interest (45%) | Interest (8% of opening debt) | Debt repaid | Closing debt |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 110 | 49.5 | 40.0 | 9.5 | 490.5 |
| 2 | 120 | 54.0 | 39.2 | 14.8 | 475.7 |
| 3 | 130 | 58.5 | 38.1 | 20.4 | 455.3 |
| 4 | 140 | 63.0 | 36.4 | 26.6 | 428.7 |
| 5 | 150 | 67.5 | 34.3 | 33.2 | 395.5 |
On paper, you would not make this table. You would say: total cash flow before interest is 45% of (110 + 120 + 130 + 140 + 150), which is 45% of 650, about 290. Debt stays near 450 on average, so interest is about 8% of 450, which is 36 a year, or 180 over five years. Debt repaid is about 290 minus 180, which is 110, so closing debt is about 390. The exact answer is 395.5, so the shortcut is within a few units.
Exit. Exit EV is 8.0 times 150, which is 1,200. Exit equity is 1,200 minus 395.5, which is about 804.5 (paper: 1,200 minus 390, about 810).
Return. The money multiple is 804.5 ÷ 300, about 2.68 times (paper: 810 over 300, 2.7 times). From the table, 2.5 times is about 20% and 3.0 times about 25%, so 2.7 times is a little over 21%. The exact figure is 21.8% a year.
Attribution. Equity gain is about 504.5. Earnings growth contributes 50 times 8.0, which is 400. The multiple does not change, so it contributes nothing. Debt repaid contributes about 104.5. The gain splits roughly 79% from earnings growth and 21% from paying down debt. If the exit multiple were 1.0 lower, exit EV would fall by 150, which is why the exit multiple is the assumption to test.
Common errors
- Forgetting to subtract debt at exit. The exit value of 1,200 belongs to all investors, not only the equity.
- Using the wrong base for the multiple. Entry equity is 300, not the 800 EV.
- Counting interest twice, or leaving it out.
- Mixing earnings and cash flow. Say what conversion you assume.
- Assuming a better exit multiple without saying so.
- Over-precision. If you spend three minutes on the first year, you will not finish.
How to practise
Time yourself: a minute on layout and conventions, two on the debt, one on exit and return. Then change one assumption and explain how the answer moves.
About this guide: it is original to Charta Learning, uses an invented company and has not yet been reviewed by an experienced practitioner. Real transactions include fees, tax, minimum cash and more complex debt, which this simplified exercise leaves out.