How to turn an insurance internship into a full-time offer
A summer or placement internship at an insurer, broker or reinsurer is usually a long interview as well as a chance to learn. This guide covers what interns are typically asked to do, how to show technical and soft skills, how to build relationships inside the firm, a phase-by-phase plan and how to handle the return-offer conversation. No behaviour guarantees an offer, and firms differ in size, structure and recruiting calendars, so treat this as general advice.
What is the internship for?
For the firm, it is a way to see how you work before committing to a hire. For you, it is a chance to see whether you like the job and the team. Decisions on return offers are often influenced by how the team judged the quality of your work and how well you fitted in, though processes differ: some firms use formal scoring, some rely on feedback from the people you worked with, and many combine both. Do not assume one good week decides it, or that one bad day does.
What work will I typically be given?
Tasks vary by team and season, but interns commonly see work like this:
- Preparing a risk summary for an underwriter: gathering facts about a prospective customer from the submission and public sources.
- Checking a pricing calculation or updating a spreadsheet of rates and loadings.
- Analysing claims data, such as how often claims occur, how large they are and whether anything has changed.
- Supporting a claims file: logging documents, chasing information and drafting a note on the status.
- Building a market or peer comparison, for example how competitors price a type of cover.
- Drafting a short presentation or briefing on a current risk, such as a weather event or a new type of liability.
What does good look like for technical work?
- Accuracy first. A correct, clearly explained analysis is worth more than a quick one with errors. Speed comes after accuracy.
- Check your own work before handing it over: do the totals agree, did you pull the right period, do the ratios make sense?
- Show how you got there. A reviewer should be able to follow your spreadsheet or note without asking you.
- Flag assumptions and say when you were not sure, for example "I assumed premiums are earned premiums".
- Flag, do not hide. If you find an error in your own or someone else's data, raise it promptly and say what you found.
- Own the follow-up. If a query is open, chase it and close it rather than waiting to be asked.
What soft skills matter?
- Communication. Give short updates at agreed times. Say early if a task will take longer than expected.
- Questions. Ask good questions once, write down the answer and do not ask the same thing twice.
- Feedback. Thank people for review comments, fix the point and apply the lesson to the next piece of work, visibly.
- Reliability. Be on time, meet deadlines, and do what you said you would.
- Humility. You are there to learn. Be willing to do routine tasks well.
- Discretion. Customer, claim and policy information is confidential and often sensitive. Do not discuss it in public places, on social media or with friends, and follow the firm's rules on data and devices.
- Customer sense. Remember there is a real person behind each file. Treat claims and customer queries with care.
- Respect. Treat assistants, juniors and seniors courteously. In remote settings, be responsive and write clearly.
Whom should I get to know inside the firm?
Your own team first, as they see your work daily. Then adjacent teams, such as claims if you are in underwriting, or actuarial if you are in pricing. Other interns are a good source of support, and often become future colleagues. Ask for short one-to-one chats of fifteen to twenty minutes, at a quiet time, with a clear aim such as learning about their route. Look for a mentor or sponsor, which may be assigned or may emerge. Thank people, avoid gossip, and do not over-network at the cost of your work. Keep your outside network warm with an occasional short update, within your confidentiality obligations.
What should I do in each phase?
First week. Learn names, systems and expectations. Ask what good looks like, take notes and do small tasks very carefully.
Middle weeks. Build pace without losing accuracy. Volunteer for a slightly bigger task when you have capacity. Seek feedback and act on it.
Mid-point. Ask for a short conversation. A simple script: "I would value your feedback so far. What am I doing well, what should I improve, and what would make the biggest difference in the time I have left?" Write down the answers and act on them.
Last two weeks. Finish open items, tidy your files, thank the people who helped and ask for a final conversation. Do not coast; the last impression counts.
How do I raise the return-offer question?
Near the end, ask your manager or mentor politely: "I have enjoyed this and would like to work here. Could you tell me how the decision is made and where I stand?" Listen to the answer without arguing. If the answer is yes, ask about next steps in writing. If it is "maybe", ask what would help and when you will hear, and thank them. If you have to wait, send a short note and keep working well.
What if there is no offer?
It happens for many reasons, including headcount, timing and the firm's needs rather than performance. Thank people, ask for specific feedback, ask whether they would act as a reference, and stay in touch. Treat what you learned as evidence for your next applications to other firms. Insurance is a connected industry, and people move between firms.
Which mistakes cost interns offers?
- Careless errors repeated after feedback.
- Hiding a mistake instead of reporting it.
- Breaching confidentiality, even casually.
- Being late or hard to reach.
- Treating customers' claims as numbers only.
- Arrogance, or treating tasks as beneath you.
- Gossip or complaining about colleagues.
- Never asking for feedback.
What to do this week
- Write down the three kinds of task you expect and how you will check each.
- Prepare a one-page note listing the firm's confidentiality and data rules.
- Draft the mid-point feedback script above in your own words.
- List five people you would like to meet and why.
- Prepare a short note of thanks you could send at the end.
About this guide: it is original to Charta Learning and has not yet been reviewed by an experienced practitioner. Names in examples are invented. Internship structure, staffing and return-offer processes differ widely between firms and offices, so rely on your firm's own guidance where it differs.