Working with headhunters and search firms
Headhunters, also called search firms or recruiters, sit between funds and candidates in many parts of the industry. Used well, they can give you useful market information and access to roles. Used badly, they can damage your reputation. This guide explains how the search industry typically works and how to deal with it. Practice varies by firm, country and year, and nothing here is a promise of any outcome.
How does the search industry work?
A fund that wants to hire may engage a search firm to find candidates. The firm talks to professionals, assesses fit, puts forward a shortlist and helps arrange interviews. Some firms specialise in one asset class or level of seniority; others cover many.
Not every fund uses them. Smaller funds, particularly in hedge funds, often hire through referrals and their own networks. Larger platforms and firms with regular, structured hiring are more likely to use search firms, and they are more common for experienced hires than for the most junior roles. Even this varies.
Who pays whom?
Typically the hiring fund pays the search firm, often through a fee tied to a successful placement. The candidate usually pays nothing, and you should be cautious about any arrangement in which you are asked to pay.
This matters because it explains the headhunter's incentives. Their client is the fund, and their income depends on a placement. A good headhunter also wants a long relationship with you, because you may be a client or a source later. Treat the relationship as friendly and professional, but not as one in which they work for you.
How do I get on their radar?
- Do your job well. Headhunters ask around, and your reputation reaches them through colleagues and seniors.
- Keep your public professional profile accurate and current.
- Respond politely when one contacts you, even if you are not looking. A courteous no is remembered.
- Ask trusted peers which search firms they have found honest and useful, and for an introduction.
- Introduce yourself to a firm that covers your area with a short note: your background, the type of move you might consider eventually, and your rough timing.
What should I say, and not say, on a first call?
Prepare as for a short interview. Have a clear thirty-second account of your background, the kind of role and fund you are interested in, and your timing.
Do say:
- Where you work, what you have done, and what you are looking for.
- What you do not want, such as a location or strategy you would not consider.
- Whether you are already speaking to other firms or processes, at a general level.
Do not say:
- Confidential details of deals, clients, portfolio positions or your employer's internal matters.
- Exaggerations about your role or results. Search firms check references.
- Criticism of your current employer or colleagues.
- Compensation figures you cannot back up. Ask what is typical and give an honest range if asked.
An example opening, with invented names: "Hello Nadia, thank you for calling. I have spent two years in leveraged finance and I am interested in mid-market buyout teams, probably next year. I am not in a hurry and I would like to understand how the market looks. I will keep deal details confidential, but I can talk about my role."
How should I prepare?
When a headhunter puts you forward, ask what the fund is looking for, who you will meet and what the format will be. Then prepare as you would for any interview: a pitch or deal you can discuss in detail, your reasons for the move, and sensible questions about the team. Ask the headhunter for honest feedback after each round, and treat it as one view among several.
How do I handle several processes and offers?
- Keep a simple tracker of each firm, stage, contact and date.
- Be truthful about where you are. If two processes are converging, tell each side that you have other conversations, without naming the other fund unless you are comfortable doing so.
- Never invent a competing offer to press a decision.
- Ask for reasonable time to decide, and give a clear answer by the date you agree.
- If you accept an offer, tell the others promptly and politely. The industry is small.
- Check your contract for notice periods, restrictive covenants and non-solicitation terms before you commit, and take legal advice if you are unsure.
What about ethics and confidentiality?
Your duty to your current employer does not stop when a search firm calls. Do not share client names, deal terms, performance data or portfolio holdings. Do not forward internal documents. Do not use your employer's equipment or time for interviews in ways that break its rules.
Be careful about exclusivity. A search firm may ask you to agree that it alone represents you. Before agreeing, think about what it commits you to, for how long and what happens if you hear of a role through someone else. Exclusivity is not necessarily wrong, but it should be a considered choice rather than a quick yes. Ask for terms in writing.
What mistakes should I avoid?
- Treating a headhunter as your only channel.
- Sending the same CV to several firms who then submit you to the same fund. Duplicate submissions can confuse the fund and weaken your position.
- Overstating your experience.
- Ghosting a process that no longer interests you.
- Discussing other candidates or other funds' confidential information.
- Assuming a friendly call is a promise of an interview.
What to do this week
- Write a thirty-second account of your background, the role you are interested in and your timing.
- Ask two trusted peers which search firms they would recommend, and why.
- Check your employment contract for confidentiality, notice and non-solicitation terms.
- Start a tracker for any conversations you have with firms or funds.
- Draft a short, honest introductory note to one firm that covers your area, and send it only when you are ready.
About this guide: it is original to Charta Learning and has not yet been reviewed by an experienced practitioner. Names in examples are invented. Fee structures, exclusivity terms and local rules vary, so read any agreement carefully and take advice where needed.