How an insurer makes money: the combined ratio explained
An insurer collects premiums today in return for a promise to pay claims later, and that gap in time is the heart of its business model. This guide walks through the income of an invented insurer, step by step, with every figure worked out, so that you can explain the combined ratio in plain words. Ratios and benchmarks here are common rules of thumb, and practice varies by line of business, country and accounting regime.
What are the two sources of profit?
An insurer earns in two ways. Underwriting profit is premiums earned less claims paid or expected and less the expenses of running the business. Investment income is what the insurer earns by investing the money it holds between receiving premiums and paying claims. A motor insurer may settle most claims within months; a liability insurer may wait years, so it holds the money for longer.
Some insurers run a small underwriting loss and still make a profit overall, because investment income more than covers it. Others aim for an underwriting profit and treat investment income as a bonus. Which is sensible depends on the line, the interest rate environment and the insurer's risk appetite.
What are the ratios?
- Loss ratio = claims divided by premiums earned. It says how much of each unit of premium goes to customers.
- Expense ratio = expenses divided by premiums. Expenses include commission to brokers, staff, systems and marketing.
- Combined ratio = loss ratio plus expense ratio.
A combined ratio below 100 percent means an underwriting profit. Above 100 percent means an underwriting loss. As a rule of thumb only, the break-even point is 100 percent, and insurers often target comfortably below it to leave room for bad years.
What does a worked example look like?
Quillbeck Mutual is an invented general insurer writing property and commercial liability cover. In its latest year it had:
- Premiums earned: 80.0m
- Claims incurred (paid plus the change in reserves): 52.0m
- Expenses: 24.0m
- Invested assets: 60.0m, earning an average return of 3.5 percent
Now the arithmetic.
- Loss ratio: 52.0 divided by 80.0 is 65.0 percent.
- Expense ratio: 24.0 divided by 80.0 is 30.0 percent.
- Combined ratio: 65.0 plus 30.0 is 95.0 percent.
- Underwriting profit: 80.0 less 52.0 less 24.0 is 4.0m, which is 5.0 percent of premiums (100 less 95).
- Investment income: 60.0 multiplied by 3.5 percent is 2.1m.
- Total profit before tax: 4.0 plus 2.1 is 6.1m.
So of the 6.1m, about two thirds (4.0 divided by 6.1, or 66 percent) came from underwriting and about one third (34 percent) from investment. The figures are simplified: real accounts also include items such as tax, reinsurance costs and movements in older reserves.
What happens in a bad year?
Suppose claims rise by 10 percent because of a run of storms and some large liability losses, while premiums and expenses stay the same.
- Claims: 52.0 multiplied by 1.10 is 57.2m.
- Loss ratio: 57.2 divided by 80.0 is 71.5 percent.
- Combined ratio: 71.5 plus 30.0 is 101.5 percent.
- Underwriting result: 80.0 less 57.2 less 24.0 is a loss of 1.2m.
- Add investment income of 2.1m: total profit of 0.9m.
A rise of only 6.5 points in the loss ratio turned a 4.0m underwriting profit into a 1.2m loss, a swing of 5.2m. That sensitivity is why pricing discipline and reserving matter so much. It also shows why investment income cushions the result without removing the problem: if interest rates fall, the cushion shrinks.
How is the break-even loss ratio found?
Break-even loss ratio = 100 percent less the expense ratio. For Quillbeck that is 100 less 30, which is 70 percent. If claims run above 70 percent of premiums, the insurer makes an underwriting loss. This is a handy mental calculation for an interview: "If expenses are 30 percent, we can afford to pay out up to 70 percent in claims before we lose money on underwriting."
Why does a ratio under 100 percent not tell the whole story?
Three cautions.
- Reserves are estimates. Claims incurred include the insurer's best estimate of claims not yet settled. If reserves turn out too high, later years show a release that flatters results; if too low, the reverse. A good combined ratio built on thin reserves can be misleading.
- Mix matters. A blend of lines may hide one unprofitable class behind a profitable one.
- One year is a sample. Catastrophe-exposed lines can look excellent for several years and then give up the profit in one event.
How do I use this in an interview?
Be ready to do three things aloud. Define the combined ratio in a sentence. Work through a small case: premiums 100, claims 70, expenses 28 gives a combined ratio of 98 percent and an underwriting profit of 2. Then explain that investment income sits on top, and that float (the money held before claims are paid) is why insurers care about both underwriting and investing. Say what you do not know, and never invent figures for a real company.
What to remember
- Profit = premiums less claims less expenses, plus investment income.
- Combined ratio = loss ratio plus expense ratio; below 100 percent means an underwriting profit.
- Small changes in the loss ratio move profit a lot, because premiums are large relative to margin.
- Reserves, mix and catastrophe years all affect how much to trust one year's ratio.
About this guide: it is original to Charta Learning and has not yet been reviewed by an experienced practitioner. Names in examples are invented. The ratios are simplified and the benchmarks are rules of thumb, and insurers define and report these measures slightly differently, so check definitions before comparing firms.