How to answer "why consulting" and "why this firm"
"Why consulting?" is often the first question in an experience interview, and one of the most commonly answered badly. Interviewers use it to see whether you understand the job, whether your reasons are real and whether you will still want it in the eighth month of a hard project. This guide shows how to build the answer, how to tailor it to a firm and an office, and what to avoid. The best answer is yours, so use this as a structure and not a script.
What is the interviewer testing?
Mostly three things. Understanding: do you know what strategy consultants do day to day, beyond the title? Evidence: have you done something that shows real interest, rather than a general attraction to a famous career? Resilience: have you thought about the demands, such as travel, long days around deadlines and giving advice rather than making the final decision, and do you still want it? A polished answer that sounds like a brochure usually fails all three.
How do I separate "why consulting" from "why strategy"?
They are different questions, and a strong answer touches both.
- Why consulting is about the way of working: short engagements, small teams, structured analysis, advising senior people, and a steep learning curve across industries.
- Why strategy is about the type of problem: where to compete, whether to enter a market, how to restore profit, whether to buy a company.
If you can say which kinds of question draw you, and why, you sound like someone who has looked closely.
How should I structure it?
Use three parts and aim for about a minute and a half.
- What draws you. Two or three specific features of the work.
- Evidence. Something you did that resembled it and that you enjoyed, ideally with a number.
- Testing and trade-off. How you checked your idea (conversations, a project, reading) and one honest cost you accept.
Practise until it is clear, then say it in your own words.
What makes a reason weak, and what makes it strong?
Weak reasons are generic: variety, learning, smart colleagues, "problem solving", prestige or pay. Many careers offer them, and the follow-up is "so why not industry?"
- Weak: "I like solving problems and I want a fast-learning environment."
- Stronger: "In my final-year project I had to work out why a student café kept running out of its best-selling items. I split it into demand and ordering, found that two products drove most of the problem, and the manager changed the ordering rule. I enjoyed going from a vague question to a recommendation someone could act on, and that is what I understand consulting to be, applied to bigger decisions."
The stronger version names something you did, shows structure and links to the job. Add a trade-off: "I know the work means advising rather than deciding, and that travel and long days come with it. I have spoken to two consultants about that, and I would rather be close to many decisions than own one for years."
How do I answer "why not industry or another career?"
Prepare a calm answer on the distinctive features of consulting: exposure to many problems early, working with senior executives and the pace of learning. Do not criticise other paths. Some interviewers also ask about exit options. Be honest that you may learn a lot and move on someday, but show that you want to build and use the skills here, not treat the job as a stopgap.
How do I answer "why this firm?"
Do the work in advance. Read the firm's public material: its areas of work, how it describes its training and staffing, its offices and any published writing. Then pick two or three reasons that are true for you.
- Type of work. A sector, function or kind of problem that the firm publicly emphasises and that connects to your interests.
- Way of working. Training, team size or style, as the firm presents them and as people you have spoken to describe them.
- People. Something you learned from conversations. Name the kind of person or event, and only name an individual if they would be comfortable with that.
- Culture. Only where you have real evidence, and without repeating marketing language.
Avoid claims about the firm's ranking, clients or results unless you are certain of the facts and the source. If you have no first-hand evidence, say that your view comes from public information and conversations, and explain what you hope to find out.
How do I answer "why this office?"
Be practical and honest. Reasons might be a language, family, a city you know, a sector concentrated there or a wish to work in a particular market. If you are open to several offices, say so and explain how you would choose. Do not claim a link you do not have.
What follow-up questions should I expect?
"What would you do if you did not get the job?" "What do you think the worst part of the job is?" "Tell me about a time you worked on something like this." "What have you done to find out about the work?" Prepare a calm, honest answer for each and avoid contradicting your CV.
What mistakes do candidates make?
Reciting a script, leading with money or status, saying the same thing to every firm, flattering the interviewer, not knowing what the firm does, exaggerating contact with consultants and being unable to answer the follow-ups.
What to do this week
- Write your three-part answer in about 200 words, then cut it to ninety seconds spoken.
- Choose two things you have done as evidence and write one sentence on each, with a number if you honestly can.
- Pick one firm and write three true reasons for it, with the public source for each.
- Write your honest answer to "why not industry?" in two sentences.
- Practise aloud with a friend who will interrupt with "why?"
About this guide: it is original to Charta Learning and has not yet been reviewed by an experienced practitioner. Names in examples are invented. Firm and programme details change, so use each firm's current public information.