How to evaluate a startup in a first meeting
A first meeting with a founder usually lasts thirty to sixty minutes, and the investor has to decide whether to spend more time. Nobody can verify everything in that time, so good investors have a short list of things to learn and a sense of what to check next. This guide gives that list and applies it to an invented company, including a bottom-up market estimate and a simple dilution calculation.
What am I trying to find out?
Whether the company could become very large, and whether this team can get there. The rest is evidence for or against. Work through six areas, and write down what you heard separately from what you believe.
What do I look for in the team?
- Why these founders for this problem: what do they know that others do not?
- Evidence they can sell, hire and build: what have they done before?
- How they respond to a hard question. Defensiveness is information, and so is a willingness to say "I do not know."
- How they work together, and who owns what.
How do I size the market from the bottom up?
Top-down sizing, such as "the market is 50 billion and we need 1%", says little. Bottom-up sizing counts customers and multiplies by what each pays:
market = number of reachable customers times annual revenue per customer.
Then ask what share is realistic in several years, and whether the company can expand to more customers or more products.
What about product and traction?
For product, ask what problem it solves, what it replaces and why the customer switches. A good sign is that customers pull the product from the founders. For traction, ask what is growing, how fast and for whom: revenue, usage, retention and pipeline. Prefer cohort retention to totals, and ask what happened to customers who left.
What are the unit economics?
- Gross margin: revenue less the direct cost of serving customers.
- Customer acquisition cost (CAC): sales and marketing spend per new customer.
- Payback: months of gross profit needed to recover CAC.
Early on these are rough, so ask how the founder expects them to change.
What about round terms?
Know how much is being raised, at what pre-money valuation, and what that sells. The investor's share is the cheque ÷ post-money, where post-money is pre-money plus the new money. Ask what the money buys: months of runway and which milestones it reaches before the next round.
Worked example: Pantrywise
The company is invented and figures are for practice. Pantrywise sells inventory software to independent restaurants. The founder says the market is huge. Here is a bottom-up check, using the founders' assumptions, which you would test.
Market. In the region, there are about 60,000 independent restaurants. Say 55% have the kind of kitchen and staffing that could use the product, which gives 60,000 times 0.55, which is 33,000 reachable sites. Price is 2,400 a year. The reachable market is 33,000 times 2,400, which is 79.2m a year. If the company won 5% of sites in five years, that is 1,650 customers and 3.96m of annual revenue.
The founder's total of 144m (60,000 times 2,400) is nearly double the reachable figure, and even the reachable market is modest for a venture-scale outcome. The question to ask is how the company grows beyond this: more regions, more products such as ordering and payments, or larger customers.
Unit economics. Gross margin is 78%, so gross profit per customer is 2,400 times 0.78, which is 1,872 a year. CAC is 1,800. Payback is 1,800 ÷ 1,872 times 12, which is about 11.5 months. Lifetime gross profit over three years is 5,616, or 3.1 times CAC. That looks healthy if retention holds, so ask about churn.
Round terms. The founders own 85% and an early angel owns 15%. The company raises 2.0m at a pre-money valuation of 8.0m. Post-money is 10.0m, so the new investor owns 2.0 ÷ 10.0, which is 20%. Founders fall from 85% to 68%, and the angel from 15% to 12%. At 2.0m, with spend of 90k a month, runway is about 22 months.
If a Series A later raises 6.0m at 24.0m pre-money, it sells 20% again. Founders then hold 0.68 times 0.8, which is 54.4%, and the angel holds 9.6%. The founders' stake is worth 6.8m at the first post-money and 16.3m at a 30m post-money, which shows dilution is not loss if the value rises.
Verdict. A good first-meeting note would say: the team is credible, the bottom-up market is about 79m, so the case depends on expansion, and unit economics look sound if retention is real. Next steps are customer calls and a retention cohort.
What should I do after the meeting?
Write a one-page note the same day: the pitch in three lines, what you learned, what you believe, what worries you and what to check. Decide pass, follow up or go deeper, and say why. Passing quickly and kindly is part of the job.
What common errors should I avoid?
- Accepting top-down market figures.
- Dividing the cheque by the pre-money to get ownership.
- Adding dilution percentages rather than multiplying.
- Falling for a polished deck over customer evidence.
- Treating early unit economics as precise.
Investors differ in how they weigh team, market and traction, and practice varies by stage.
About this guide: it is original to Charta Learning, uses an invented company and has not yet been reviewed by an experienced practitioner. Real term sheets include option pools, preferences and other terms this simplified example leaves out.