Charta is on Google Play: practise on the go. Get the app

How to pitch a short idea: catalysts, borrow cost, sizing and stops

23 October 2026 · 5 min read · Charta Learning

A short pitch asks the team to bet that a share price will fall. It is harder to get right than a long pitch, and interviewers and portfolio managers know it. This guide explains why shorts differ, what a convincing pitch contains and how the arithmetic of borrow cost and position size works, using an invented stock.

What makes a short different from a long?

Four things change.

What does a good short pitch contain?

Use the same structure as any pitch, then add what is specific to shorts.

  1. Thesis. Why the price is too high, in two sentences. Typical sources are aggressive accounting, a deteriorating business, a fashion that is fading, or expectations that cannot be met.
  2. Valuation and downside. What the shares are worth on your numbers, and the price you expect.
  3. Catalyst. A dated event that will make others see it: results, a guidance cut, a covenant test, the end of a lock-up. Without one, a short can drift against you for a long time.
  4. Borrow and squeeze risk. Cost to borrow, how crowded the short is, and how easily the shares can be recalled.
  5. Sizing and stop. How much, and what would make you leave.
  6. What would change my mind.

What are borrow cost and squeeze risk?

The borrow fee is quoted as an annual percentage of the value of the shares borrowed. Easy-to-borrow large companies cost little; scarce shares can cost a lot, and the fee can rise after you enter.

Crowding is measured by short interest as a share of the free float, and by days to cover: short interest ÷ average daily trading volume. A high figure means that, if shorts must buy back at once, there are few sellers to meet them. A squeeze happens when a rising price forces shorts to buy, which pushes the price higher still. A recall, where the lender asks for shares back and none can be found, forces the same result. A catalyst that others also see makes a crowded short more dangerous, not less.

How do the numbers work? A worked example

The company is invented: Pemberley Outfitters, a clothing retailer. Figures are for practice only.

Setup. The share price is £50. Free float is 45 million shares and 9 million are sold short, so short interest is 9 ÷ 45, which is 20% of the float. Average daily volume is 1.5 million shares, so days to cover are 9 ÷ 1.5, which is 6. Borrow costs 6% a year. The fund has £10 million of capital. You short 2,000 shares: a position of £100,000, 1% of the fund. Thesis: results in about six months will show falling sales and an inventory problem, and you think the shares are worth 35. You pay no dividends.

Borrow cost. 6% of 100,000 for half a year is £3,000, or £1.50 per share.

Outcomes after six months (profit is gain on the shares minus the £3,000 borrow cost).

Exit priceGain on sharesAfter borrow costReturn on the 100,000Position value
3530,00027,000+27%70,000
4020,00017,000+17%80,000
500-3,000-3%100,000
65-30,000-33,000-33%130,000
75-50,000-53,000-53%150,000
100-100,000-103,000-103%200,000

Read the table carefully. The best case, a fall to zero, is a gain of £100,000 before costs. A rise to £100 loses more than the whole starting position, and nothing stops it going further. Standing still loses £3,000, so the stock must fall by at least £1.50 just to break even.

Sizing and stop. At a 1% weight, a doubling of the price costs £103,000 including borrow, about 1.03% of a £10 million fund. Suppose you set a stop at £60. The loss is £10 times 2,000 shares, which is £20,000, plus £3,000 borrow, so £23,000, or 0.23% of the fund. The target of 35 gains £27,000 after cost, or 0.27%. That is a reward-to-risk ratio of 27,000 ÷ 23,000, about 1.2. Before cost it is 15 against 10, or 1.5. A pitch should state this ratio and ask whether the catalyst and the crowding justify it. With 20% of the float short and 6 days to cover, a sharp rise could pass the stop before you can trade, so the stop is a plan, not a guarantee.

How should I set a stop?

Decide before entering. Two kinds are common: a price level, as above, and a thesis stop, meaning the facts that would show you are wrong, such as sales stabilising. Many managers combine them. Practitioners differ on strict price stops, since some argue a rising price on a good short is a chance to add, while others cut losses mechanically. Whichever you choose, be consistent and say why.

What mistakes do candidates make?

About this guide: it is original to Charta Learning, uses an invented company and has not yet been reviewed by an experienced practitioner. Real borrow terms, margin rules and recall rights vary by market and broker, and this example ignores margin, interest on cash and taxes.

More guides

Practise with questions that explain every wrong answer, and a plan built from a short diagnostic.

Start free →

Charta Learning is independent. It is not affiliated with, sponsored by or endorsed by any bank, fund or consultancy. All questions, cases and notes are original, written for this product with invented companies and public information only; none is a real question from any firm's recruitment process. Feedback on written answers is AI-assisted and can be wrong. The legal and documentation topics are general education, not legal advice. We do not guarantee interviews, offers or results.