How to pitch a long-only idea in an asset management interview
A long-only pitch argues that a portfolio should own a share, and says by how much more or less than the benchmark does. This guide sets out a structure you can speak in a few minutes, shows how sizing works as an active weight, and explains how the pitch differs from a hedge fund one. The company and every figure are invented.
What does an interviewer want from a long-only pitch?
Usually three things: a clear reason the market is wrong or too slow, a sensible view of what you would pay for quality, and an understanding that you are running someone else's money against a benchmark and written guidelines. Expect questions on valuation, risk and what would make you sell. Practitioners differ on style, so state yours: value, growth, quality or a blend.
What is the structure?
- Thesis. Two sentences: what the company does well, and why the shares do not reflect it.
- Valuation versus the benchmark and peers. The multiple you use, how it compares and what you think it should be.
- Quality. Returns on capital, cash generation, balance sheet, management and, at overview level, environmental, social and governance factors that could affect value.
- Risks. The two or three things that would hurt the thesis, and how likely and large each is.
- Catalyst and horizon. What will make others notice, and how long you expect to wait. Long-only horizons are often years, but a good pitch still says what happens in the next 12 months.
- Sizing as an active weight. Your weight less the benchmark weight.
- What would make you sell. Price reached, thesis broken, or a better use of the money.
What does a worked example look like?
Invented: Dunmerrow Foods, a UK-listed food producer. The benchmark is a UK equity index, and the portfolio is £400m.
Valuation. The share price is £8.00 and next-year earnings per share are £0.64, so the price-earnings ratio is 8.00 ÷ 0.64, which is 12.5 times. The benchmark trades on 16 times and listed food peers on 15 times. You argue the discount is too wide for a business with stable margins and low debt.
Base case. Earnings grow 8 per cent a year for two years: 0.64 times 1.08 squared is 0.746. At 15 times, the price is 0.746 times 15, which is £11.20, a gain of 40 per cent on the price. Dividends of £0.26 a year add £0.52, so total value is £11.72 and the total return is 11.72 ÷ 8.00 minus 1, which is 46 per cent over two years.
Bear case. Earnings fall 10 per cent to 0.576 and the multiple stays near 11 times: 0.576 times 11 is £6.34, a fall of about 21 per cent before dividends.
So the base case offers about 46 per cent against a downside of roughly 21 per cent. Say which is more likely and why. A bear case you do not believe is not a bear case.
Sizing. The company is 1.0 per cent of the benchmark. You propose 2.5 per cent of the portfolio, an active weight of plus 1.5 percentage points. In money, 2.5 per cent of £400m is £10m. At £8.00 that is 1.25 million shares. If average daily volume is 2 million shares and you limit trading to 20 per cent of volume, you can buy 400,000 shares a day, so building the position takes about 3.1 trading days. Say so: liquidity limits sizing, and a high-conviction idea in an illiquid share is still capped by what you can sell.
Why is position size an active weight?
A benchmark-relative manager is judged on difference from the benchmark. Holding 1.0 per cent when the benchmark weight is 1.0 per cent is a neutral position. Owning 2.5 per cent is an overweight and a bet. Not owning it is an underweight, also a bet. Sizing therefore reflects conviction, risk (a volatile share deserves a smaller active weight), liquidity and the overall tracking error the guidelines allow. Mention these four, and that the rest of the portfolio must fund the overweight.
How does it differ from a hedge fund pitch?
- The yardstick is relative. A long-only manager can do well by owning the right shares and still lose money in a falling market, and clients usually accept that. A hedge fund usually aims for a positive return whatever the market does.
- There is no short side. Ideas to avoid appear as underweights, and a manager cannot underweight by more than the benchmark weight, which limits the bet.
- Horizon is often longer. Quality and compounding matter more, and a catalyst is helpful but not essential.
- Sizing is relative to the index and to guidelines, not to a risk budget on a gross and net book.
- Fiduciary duty and client communication matter: you should be able to explain the idea to a client in plain terms.
Practitioners and firms differ on how much each matters.
What would make you sell?
Prepare three triggers: the price reaches your target, so the expected return no longer pays for the risk; the thesis breaks, for example margins fall for a structural reason; or a better idea needs the money. A fourth, a change in the company's governance or conduct, may also be a reason to exit or to engage. Avoid saying you would never sell.
What mistakes do candidates make?
- Pitching a good company with no view on price.
- Ignoring the benchmark and the active weight.
- Giving a bear case that is not credible.
- Forgetting liquidity and how long it takes to build the position.
- Using a hedge fund framing, such as a hedge or a stop, without saying it does not apply.
About this guide: it is original to Charta Learning, uses an invented company and has not yet been reviewed by an experienced practitioner. The example ignores trading costs, taxes and the effect on tracking error, and real guidelines on position limits vary by mandate.