How to answer "why investment banking"
"Why investment banking?" is one of the most predictable questions in the process, and one of the most often answered badly. Interviewers use it to see whether you understand the job, whether your reasons are real and whether you will stay the course when the hours are long. This guide shows how to build the answer, how to tailor it to a bank and a group, and what to avoid. The best answer is yours, so use this as a structure rather than a script.
What is the interviewer actually testing?
Mostly three things. First, understanding: do you know what bankers do day to day, beyond the title? Second, evidence: have you done anything that shows genuine interest rather than a general attraction to finance? Third, resilience: have you thought about the demands, including long and unpredictable hours, repetition of detail and tight deadlines, and do you still want it? A polished answer that sounds like a brochure fails all three.
How should I structure it?
A three-part structure keeps it short, about ninety seconds.
- What draws you. One or two specific things about the work, such as advising a company on a major decision, working with numbers and judgement together, or learning many industries quickly.
- Evidence. Something you did that shows it, such as a valuation project, a student fund, a case competition, following a deal in detail, or a conversation with a banker that changed your view.
- Fit. Why your skills suit the demands: accuracy, stamina, teamwork, communication.
Practise it until it is clear, then tell it in your own words so that it does not sound memorised.
What makes a reason weak, and what makes it strong?
Weak reasons are generic: money, prestige, "fast-paced environment", "I like finance". They apply to anyone and invite the follow-up "so why not consulting or a corporate role?"
Stronger reasons are specific and show that you understand a trade-off.
- Weak: "I want to work on large, exciting deals."
- Stronger: "I enjoyed valuing a small listed retailer for a society competition. The part I liked was arguing for a range and defending the assumptions, and I realised advisory work is about that judgement, applied to a client's real decision."
Also prepare an honest answer on the alternatives. If asked why not consulting or industry, you can say what is distinctive about banking: the transaction focus, the pace of learning and working with senior decision-makers. Avoid criticising other careers.
How do I talk about the hours without exaggerating or ignoring them?
Acknowledge that the job is demanding, and do not claim to enjoy long hours for their own sake. A credible line is: "I know the hours can be long and unpredictable around deadlines. I have managed demanding periods before, for example during my exams while running the society's budget, and I want work where the effort goes to something I care about." Do not claim facts about any bank's actual hours unless you have heard them from a first-hand source, and even then say so.
How do I answer "why this bank?"
Do the work in advance. Read the bank's public information: its divisions, the sectors and regions it emphasises, recent public announcements and the structure of its programme. Then pick two or three reasons that are true for you.
- Programme and training. What the scheme offers and why that suits how you learn.
- Focus. A sector, region or type of deal the bank is known for in public sources, that links to your interests.
- People. Something you learned from a conversation with a banker or at an event. Name the type of person or event, and only name an individual if they would be happy for you to.
- Culture. Only if you have real evidence, and without repeating marketing language.
Avoid claiming league table positions or deals unless you are certain of the facts and the source.
How do I answer "why this group?"
Divide it into the work and the fit.
- The work. In M&A, you might talk about the process and structuring and valuation. In ECM or DCM, you might focus on market timing and pricing. In coverage, the relationship and the sector. In sales and trading, markets, speed and risk. Describe the work accurately.
- Fit. Link it to your skills and to the evidence you have, such as a project, course or conversation.
- Honesty about uncertainty. If you are unsure between two groups, say so, explain what you are testing, and show you have thought about it.
What follow-up questions should I expect?
"What deal have you followed?" "What do you think a banker does on a typical day?" "What would you do if you did not get the job?" "What worries you about the role?" Prepare a calm answer for each. For the deal question, choose a transaction you can explain in structured terms: parties, rationale, price, alternatives and what could go wrong.
What mistakes do candidates make?
Reciting a script, giving only money and status as reasons, sounding the same for every bank, not knowing the group's work, exaggerating knowledge, criticising other careers and being unable to answer the follow-ups.
What to do this week
- Write your three-part answer in about 200 words, then cut it to ninety seconds spoken.
- Find the evidence: choose two things you have done that support it and write one sentence on each.
- Pick one bank and write three specific, true reasons for it.
- Write what each of the groups you are considering actually does, in your own words.
- Practise out loud with a friend who will ask "so why not consulting?"
About this guide: it is original to Charta Learning and has not yet been reviewed by an experienced practitioner. Names in examples are invented. Bank and programme details change, so use each bank's current public information.