Your stock pitch as a calling card
For a hedge fund role, the strongest thing you can show is how you think about a security. A short, well-made stock pitch does that better than a list of interests. It becomes a calling card: something you can send when asked, bring up in conversation and defend aloud. This guide explains how to build one, how to keep a track record honestly and how to share it without overclaiming.
What should a stock pitch writing sample contain?
Keep it to one or two pages. A reader will give it a few minutes, and the discipline of brevity is part of the evidence. Include these parts.
- Thesis. In two or three sentences, what you think, why the market is mistaken, and what you would do (buy, or sell short).
- The business. What it does, how it earns money, and the one or two facts that matter most.
- Valuation. A simple and explicit view. Say what you used, such as a multiple of earnings or cash flow, what the market implies, and what you think it is worth, with the arithmetic shown. Show a base case and a downside.
- Catalysts. Specific events or developments that could close the gap between price and value, with rough timing. A cheap stock without a reason for the market to notice can stay cheap.
- Risks. What could go wrong, ranked by importance, and how you would monitor each.
- What would change my mind. The facts that would make you wrong, stated in advance. This is the part experienced readers look for first.
- Sizing and exit. Briefly: how large a position you would take and when you would sell.
Use only public information, and cite where each fact comes from. Do not include any material you were given in confidence, for example at an internship.
How do I build an investment journal?
A journal is a running record of ideas, kept honestly. For each idea write, on the day you form the view, the date, price, thesis, valuation, catalysts, risks and what would change your mind. Add a short review at set intervals. Do not alter the original entry afterwards.
A journal does two things for you. It proves your work is yours, because it is dated. And it teaches you, because looking back shows where your reasoning was weak. Many candidates find that their best interview answers come from entries that went wrong.
How do I keep a track record honestly?
Be strict, because a record is only useful if it can be believed.
- Record the idea and the price before the outcome is known, not afterwards.
- Include the ideas that did not work. Showing only the winners is selective and is easily noticed.
- Say whether the positions were real, paper or in a student fund, and be clear which.
- Compare with a sensible benchmark, and state the period. A good result over a few months says little, and it is better to say so than to imply otherwise.
- Separate skill from luck in your own account. "The thesis was about margins; the shares rose because of an unrelated takeover" is more credible than taking credit.
How do I share it without overclaiming?
Describe what you did, not what it proves. Compare.
Before: "My stock pitch outperformed the market and shows I can find winners."
After: "This two-page pitch sets out a view on a small retailer, with a valuation and the three risks I would watch. The shares have risen since I wrote it, but the period is short and I would treat that as inconclusive. I am more interested in whether my reasoning on margins holds up."
Offer the sample when it is relevant, for example when someone asks what you follow, and not as an attachment to a first message. Be ready for the reader to disagree and for questions about every number. If you did not do something yourself, do not claim it.
Also be careful with the law and with your employer's rules. Write about securities as analysis and not as personal recommendations to others, and do not publish anything that would breach a restriction from a current or past role.
A one-page template
Copy this layout and fill each part. The company here is invented.
Brewhaven Foods: a short idea (date, price)
- Recommendation: Buy / short. One sentence.
- Thesis: Two or three sentences. Why the market is wrong.
- Business: What it does, how it makes money, the key figure.
- Valuation: Method, key inputs, base case value, downside value, upside value. Show the arithmetic.
- Catalysts: Three, with rough timing.
- Risks: Three, ranked, with how you would monitor each.
- What would change my mind: Two or three specific facts.
- Sizing and exit: Position size idea and the conditions to sell.
- Sources: Where each fact came from.
Put a date on it, and do not revise it silently. If you update, add a dated note.
What are the common mistakes?
- A thesis with no valuation, or a valuation with no thesis.
- Catalysts that are only hopes.
- Risks that are generic, such as "the economy slows".
- Copying the views of analysts without checking them.
- Claiming certainty. Investors respect probabilities.
No writing sample guarantees an interview. It gives you something concrete to discuss.
What to do this week
- Choose one company and write the thesis in three sentences.
- Fill in the template for it, one page, with the sources.
- Start your journal with today's date and today's price.
- Write down the three facts that would make you wrong.
- Show it to one person who will disagree, and note what they challenge.
About this guide: it is original to Charta Learning and has not yet been reviewed by an experienced practitioner. The company in the template is invented. This is educational and not investment advice.