Real estate returns explained: NOI, cap rate, IRR, multiple and DSCR
Real estate interviews use a small set of return and debt measures, and the skill is knowing what each one measures and which to use when. This guide defines them in plain terms, then works one invented property through all of them with figures computed in advance. Conventions differ slightly between markets, so state yours when you answer.
What do the main measures mean?
- Net operating income (NOI): the cash a property earns before financing, tax and capital expenditure. It is rent and recoveries, less vacancy and the operating costs the landlord bears.
- Cap rate (capitalisation rate): NOI ÷ value or price. It is a yield, not a return: it ignores growth, capex and what happens at sale. Value is NOI ÷ the cap rate.
- Yield on cost: stabilised NOI ÷ the total cost of the project, including land, construction, fees and financing. It is the usual measure for a development or heavy refurbishment. The gap between yield on cost and the exit cap rate is the margin for risk.
- Unlevered IRR: the annual return on the property's cash flows with no debt. Cash out at purchase, NOI each year, sale proceeds at the end.
- Levered IRR: the same, after debt. Equity is the price less the loan, cash flows are NOI less debt service, and the sale proceeds are net of repaying the loan.
- Equity multiple: total cash returned to equity ÷ equity invested. It ignores timing, so a quick 1.5 times and a slow 1.5 times look the same.
- Cash-on-cash return: one year's cash flow after debt service ÷ equity invested. It is an income measure, not a total return.
- Debt service cover ratio (DSCR): NOI ÷ debt service (interest plus scheduled principal). On an interest-only loan, the same figure is the interest cover.
- Loan to value (LTV): the loan ÷ the property's value.
- Debt yield: NOI ÷ the loan. It ignores interest rate and cap rate.
Worked example: Pellerin Yard
Pellerin Yard is an invented multi-let industrial estate. All figures are in millions and were computed by a short calculation before writing.
Conventions: price equals value; no purchase or sale costs, tax or capex, to keep the example clear; a five-year hold; NOI grows 3% a year from 1.200; the loan is interest only; exit value is year-5 NOI ÷ the exit cap rate; cash flows arrive at each year end.
Entry. NOI in place is 1.200 and the cap rate at purchase is 6.0%, so the price is 1.200 ÷ 0.06, which is 20.0. The lender provides 60% LTV, so debt is 12.0 and equity is 8.0. The loan costs 5.0%, so interest is 0.600 a year. Debt yield is 1.200 ÷ 12.0, which is 10.0%.
Operating cash flows.
| Year | NOI | Interest | Cash flow to equity |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1.236 | 0.600 | 0.636 |
| 2 | 1.273 | 0.600 | 0.673 |
| 3 | 1.311 | 0.600 | 0.711 |
| 4 | 1.351 | 0.600 | 0.751 |
| 5 | 1.391 | 0.600 | 0.791 |
Exit. The exit cap rate is 6.5%, 50 basis points above entry, a cautious assumption because buildings age. Exit value is 1.391 ÷ 0.065, which is 21.40. After repaying the 12.0 loan, equity receives 9.40, plus the year-5 operating cash flow of 0.791, a total of 10.19 in year 5.
Unlevered return. Cash flows are minus 20.0, then 1.236, 1.273, 1.311, 1.351 and (1.391 + 21.40 =) 22.79. The unlevered IRR is 7.7% a year, and the unlevered multiple is 1.40 times.
Levered return. Equity cash flows are minus 8.0, then 0.636, 0.673, 0.711, 0.751 and 10.19. The levered IRR is 11.6% a year. Equity receives 12.96 in total, so the equity multiple is 12.96 ÷ 8.0, which is 1.62 times.
Income and cover. Year-1 cash-on-cash is 0.636 ÷ 8.0, which is 7.9%, rising to 9.9% in year 5. DSCR in year 1 is 1.236 ÷ 0.600, which is 2.06 times. LTV at exit is 12.0 ÷ 21.40, which is 56%.
Where did the return come from? Of the 4.96 total profit to equity (12.96 less 8.0), income after interest gives 3.56, and the sale price rises by 1.40 over the purchase price. Growth in NOI helped, but the cap rate moved against you by 50 basis points, which cost value. Say this in an interview: the return is income, plus growth, plus or minus the change in yield, amplified by debt.
What does leverage do, and when does it hurt?
Leverage raised the return from 7.7% to 11.6% here because the unlevered return was higher than the 5.0% cost of debt. If the unlevered return falls below the cost of debt, leverage reduces the return. Test it: with an exit cap rate of 8.0%, the unlevered IRR drops to about 4.1% and the levered IRR to about 2.7%. Debt also adds risk: the same fall in value wipes out more of a smaller equity cheque.
Sensitivity to the exit cap rate
| Exit cap rate | Exit value | Levered IRR | Equity multiple |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6.0% | 23.19 | 14.7% | 1.84 times |
| 6.5% | 21.40 | 11.6% | 1.62 times |
| 7.0% | 19.87 | 8.6% | 1.43 times |
A single half-point move changes the levered IRR by about three percentage points. That is why exit yield is the assumption to defend.
What mistakes should I avoid?
- Calling the cap rate a return. It is a yield on one year's income.
- Including capex or financing costs in NOI.
- Quoting the equity multiple without a time period.
- Dividing a levered cash flow by the price instead of the equity.
- Using an exit cap rate below entry without a reason.
- Judging leverage by IRR alone and ignoring cover and LTV.
- Mixing in-place and forward NOI without saying so.
How should I practise?
Rebuild the table above from scratch with a different cap rate, rent growth or loan. Then explain in two sentences what changed. A real transaction would include purchase costs, capex, taxes and amortising debt, so add them once the core logic is secure.
About this guide: it is original to Charta Learning, uses an invented property and has not yet been reviewed by an experienced practitioner. Terminology differs between markets, for example in how yields are quoted with or without purchaser's costs, so state your convention.